1. A Glorious Return

Week: Week 17

The Chuck Pagano story was the most heartwarming storyline of the entire season. The Colts and their entire organization rallied around their leukemia-stricken coach, taking on the motto "Chuckstrong" and throughout the entire season showing their solidarity regardless of whether it was through shaving their heads or raising money. That Pagano returned cancer-free to the sidelines in Week 17 was triumph enough; that the Colts pulled of a dramatic win heading into the playoffs was a dream scenario. Pagano's postgame dance celebration, while profoundly goofy and distinctly white, was something all fans could enjoy.