Wifey Of: Derek Jeter, New York Yankees (MLB)
This one, while juicy to say the least, didn't have a lot of legs. Johansson was spotted out in Los Angeles with Derek Jeter in December of 2004, and while she shot down any notions that they were dating, their meeting is curious to say the least. What could these two possibly share in common beyond being famous? Jeter is a good 10 years older and lives on the complete opposite side of the country; there is a 0% chance that this was a dinner between friends. Think what you will.