14. Minka Kelly
Favorite Team(s): New York Yankees (MLB)
Dated An Athlete?: Derek Jeter (Shortstop, New York Yankees)
Although there aren't any confirmed statistics, it's safe to say most female Yankee fans have fantasized about Derek Jeter. A lucky few have actually rounded the bases with the future hall of fame shortstop. Minka Kelly is one of the most impressive accomplishments in his illustrious career. The two dated for a little over three years between 2008 and 2011, and in that time Jeter won his fifth World Series ring. Sadly though, Minka didn't get a wedding ring, but she did manage a consolation prize: bragging rights.