Game: Indianapolis Colts @ Tampa Bay Buccaneers
In a game that everyone knew was over (except for the Colts), even the announcers, the Colts marched back from a 35 - 14 deficit to bring the game to a tie with 3:47 left. Led by soon-to-be first time MVP Peyton Manning, the Colts rallied back to win 38 - 35 in OT.
14. Peyton's 4th Quarter Comeback