23. Between the Legs
Game: Regular Season Game vs. Cleveland Indians
The 2010 season wasn't particularly spectacular for the Sox, their 88-74 record was good for second place in the Central. But Mark Buehrle's between the legs, jump-off-your-couch-screaming putout on Opening Day set the standard for amazing defense—so much so that Baseball Tonight began measuring web gems against the "Buehrle Meter."