12. Jay F***in Feely
Game and Outcome: Seattle Seahawks 24, New York Giants 21
Kicker Jay Feely had the opportunity to hit the game-winning field goals three times and just couldn't get it done. We're pretty sure that after the second miss, he realized he wasn't feeling it and the whole "you'll get 'em next time" phrase was just a touchy-feely subject. Ya feel us? Soundtrack, please! OK, OK, we'll stop.