Score: Canisius 79, North Carolina State 78

This game was played so long ago...they didn't even bother seeding teams. Or taking photos. Or providing much info about what actually went down during the contest. But according to Google, it happened and everyone was shocked when a small school from—*checks Google again*—Buffalo, N.Y. knocked off the Wolfpack. That's why than 50 years later, the mascot still has something to smile about.