Nike Zoom LeBron III "White Navy" vs Nike Zoom Kobe I "Home/81 Points" 

Game: Cleveland Cavaliers @ Los Angeles Lakers (1/12/2006)
Stats: LeBron: 28 points, 9 assists; Kobe: 27 points, 2 assists
Winner: Lakers 99-98
Sneaker Winner: Nike Zoom Kobe I "Home" 
LeBron was a part of damn near half of the Cavs points but it wasn't enough to take down The Lake Show. LeBron's IIIs were a great successor to his first official sneaker bearing his name but Kobe's first Nike shoe slighted them just a little — we gotta go with Kobe.