After their funny contributions to viral YouTube clips, John Boyega, Tom Hiddleston and Benedict Cumberbatch somehow tricked us into thinking every actor can do an amazing impression of another celebrity. When it comes to Josh Brolin, however, that is simply not the case. The Hail, Caesar! star appeared on The Tonight Show starring Jimmy Fallon alongside master chameleon Kate McKinnon for a rousing game of celebrity impressions.

It’s almost unfair to put him against a Saturday Night Live cast member, but Fallon’s lackluster take on Mike Tyson seemed to even things out. It wasn’t until Brolin landed on Kim Kardashian that the game went from comedic to an American horror story. Brolin relied on a tissue box and hairflips as guessing clues, and it just...was.

Check out the video above and see if Kim should take legal action for this atrocity.