Last week, we learned that Amy Poehler had stolen Seth Meyers’ credit card and was taking it on a cross-country spending spree. Well, “stolen” may be harsh; the former Saturday Night Live castmates had dinner, split the bill, accidentally swapped cards, realized it later, and now Poehler is having some innocent fun at her friend’s expense.

Except she still won’t return the card. And now, she’s got an accomplice: Tina Fey.

While Meyers had previously believed Fey to be a “really responsible person” who would get Poehler to end her little game, it appears that the opposite may be true. Take a look:

And so the saga continues.

[via Vulture]