Having get-togethers with your buddies makes for great bonding experiences. Sharing stories—like how you caught your boss picking his noise at the office—with a beer in your hand and your feet up on the sofa can often be the highlight of the night. But what to do when you are all out of stories about Mary, Jenny, and that pesky boss? It’s time to play some games.

While online gaming has become the norm the past couple years, there’s still something to be said about being there in person. From talking trash to a friendly shove, long-lasting friendships are made or broken during these sessions. So with last week’s console release of Diablo III still on our mind—and on our console—check out our list of some of the best games to play in-person with your friends and a cold brew.