Played by: Jason Biggs and Alyson Hannigan

Jim may have infamously given the D to the pie, but he handed his heart to Michelle, who was thankfully a human and not a pastry. Whereas other teen comedies left us imagining the happily-ever-after of its protagonists, sequels like American Wedding have shown us that post-teen coupledom is just as much worth watching. 

[GIF via]