Address: 495 Montauk Hwy.

When the urge strikes for a simple steak thrown on the rental's grill, skip the generic grocery store run for a whirl through this family-owned East Quogue butcher shop that also showcases from-scratch mozzarella and pasta, and an array of olive oils and cookies. Nicknamed Sonny's Prime Meats, it's an old-school slice of euphoria, where friendly staff churn out homemade sausages and custom cuts of prime-aged beef.