Alexis Bledel’s turn as a troubled and lonely housewife on Mad Men was insanely sexy, so maybe we shouldn't have been so surprised when she wound up engaged in real life to her on-screen lover Vincent Kartheiser. They had been dating about a year before the erstwhile Pete Campbell popped the question in March.

“I keep saying girlfriend," Kartheiser said. "And then I'm like, 'I mean, my fiancée! I'm a very lucky man."

They hit the beach in Hawaii in matching swimsuits over Memorial Day—it’s probably safe to say they’ll have more luck than their Mad Men alter egos.