Appeared on: Flavor of Love, Season 2 (2006); Flavor of Love Girls: Charm School (2007); Love & Hip Hop: Atlanta (2012-present)

Originally known as Buckeey on Flavor of Love, Shay has managed to make a TV career out of pursuing unattainable men. To her credit, no one believes any of the contestants really wanted Flavor Flav. Unfortunately, she lost that fight all the same. To go from that kind of defeat to looking like the sideline character in Lil' Scrappy's love life, well, what else is there to say but: The thirst is real. Shay's been cashing in on that desert for more than five years now. We'd love to see her find a boyfriend.