Couple Nickname: None
Dated Between: 2010

Jennifer Aniston may have found happiness with fiancé Justin Theroux, but a few years ago, the tabloids were abuzz about her relationship with Bounty Hunter co-star Gerard Butler. They seemed fairly into each other, but the relationship was so public during its duration that suspicions about its authenticity were raised quite a bit.

Though they never admitted to actually dating—they used the lame excuse of just being "good friends"—their PDA was too hard too miss, and seeing as how The Bounty Hunter was so awful that it needed the publicity, it sort of all makes sense to say the two were putting on a show.