1. Shay Mitchell
Show: Pretty Little Liars
In the teen murder mystery series, our former Hot Complex plays the shy yet beautiful military brat Emily, the Liar whose secret was that she's a lesbian. She's confidently out now, but she was put in front of the firing squad for crushing on her best friend Alison and dating Maya (played by Bianca Lawson), amongst other cute girls. We know, it's a strange feeling to be attracted to a girl you're also jealous of, but we're sure you'll deal with it.