Let me start by saying that I was really only looking to hook up. I had just been dumped by my boyfriend and am not the bar type and so I figured that online dating would be a reasonable option. I used a local personals service ("_city_dating.com") and had been talking to a guy for about two days before agreeing to meet him. "Mike" had told me that he used online dating because he was suffering from depression and was on medication that made it hard for him to perform. He decided that it was easier to meet girls this way than to meet up in person and then have to explain when they started getting physical. He went on to tell me though that he "had a good feeling" about me and that I was "exciting" to him despite his medication. Okay. I was cool with this and decided to go over to his place to see if we really did have chemistry since we both seemed to be looking for the same thing (a hook-up).
When I got there, he was waiting for me in the living room and we started making out. I could tell that he was getting a little aroused but was having some issues and so when he said that he knew what would "help" and that it was in his bedroom...I willingly followed. Walking in I couldn't help but notice his bed...surrounded by cat condos. Lots of cat condos. (Some structured to be as tall as I was). I knew he had cats but I assumed he meant one or two and that they were just hiding when I came over. Nope. He had nine (or ten?). Which all came out from under the bed when we sat on it. And all went to their perches on the cat condos to watch us (after rubbing against him and being petted quickly).
He then proceeded to start making out with me again and was...well...massively aroused at this point. I was massively creeped out. I like cats (I have two myself)...but having them watch me pee freaks me out much less watching me have sex. I excused myself openly admitting that this was too weird for me and left. He followed me and begged me to give him another chance and "help" him. I left.
For the next few days he messaged me asking me to come over and saying that he had "made progress" with me. I blocked him after receiving a photo of him nude, on the bed, surrounded by the cats. —Anonymous