Original Show: Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Played By: Eliza Dushku
The Pitch: Faith might be the only character on this list who was actually supposed to get her own spinoff. Eliza Dushku put the kibosh on that one before she joined the ranks of David Boreanaz (Angel), as she was in demand at the time and understandably wanted to try some non-vampire-slaying roles. Though a show starring Faith wouldn't be much more than a darker, edgier Buffy, that wouldn't be a bad thing. A source close to the project described the proposed spinoff as, "probably on a motorcycle, crossing the Earth, trying to find her place in the world." Vague, but we're down to watch the screener.