Address: Multiple Locations
What To Order: Yeah, they only make a few kinds of pizza, but when those few kinds are that good, it's really all you need. The Union Square joint that spawned two more locations still serves the best iterations of their namesake artichoke white slice, a grandma pie, and massively underrated crab pie, and that little extra cash you spend on these pizzas will go a long way with friends.
Price: $24-$30/Pie (Serves 3-5)