48. More of Me
Original Air Date: November 17, 2007
Director: Daisy von Scherler Mayer
Stars: Molly Shannon, Steven Weber, Kimberly Huie
Lesson Learned: Be careful what you wish for.
Since the producers at Lifetime know that what everyone really wants in life is more of Molly Shannon, they generously quenched that collective thirst in the form of 2007's More of Me. Her character Alice, an overextended wife, mother of twins, and dedicated activist, wishes there was an easier way to juggle it all. In true Are You Afraid of the Dark fashion, three clones pop out of her three-way mirror, each stepping in to handle a different aspect of her life.
Though they don't collectively turn on her and try to butcher her in her sleep, no one really wants to watch someone else banging their husband—even if it is a well-meaning doppelganger. Cue the George Bailey-esque wake-up call.