18. Brooke Davis and Peyton Sawyer (Sophia Bush and Hilarie Burton) as Goth Rocker and Devil in One Tree Hill
Episode: "An Attempt to Tip the Scales"
Air Date: 10/26/05
Best friends Brooke and Peyton were also sometimes rivals during One Tree Hill's high school years, because at one time or another they are both into the same guy. Eye-grabbing costumes at Peyton's Halloween party are a must then, with both staying true to their roots: Peyton went hot rocker goth, and Brooke does what she does best in a shamelessly slutty devil costume.