Sex partner: Each other with Kari Ann Peniche
Year it leaked: 2009
Her tape is perhaps one of the most disappointing sex tapes ever circulated, as it features no actual sex. In fact, it's just Gayheart, best known as the girl in Jawbreaker (1999), husband Dane (yeah, the dude from Grey's Anatomy), and disgraced beauty contestant Peniche hanging out naked.

Real or fake?: Real