The Producers: Lee Meredith (1968) vs. Uma Thurman (2005)
In The Producers, both women play Ulla, a sexy Swedish actress looking for a role in Max Bialystock and Leo Bloom's production of Springtime For Hitler. Ulla eventually nabs the part and performs a song titled "If You Got It, Flaunt It."
Ladies, we couldn't agree more. While they're both incredibly sexy, Lee Meredith just looks like she was born to play the role, and nothing Thurman does can trump the image we have of her dancing the Batusi in Pulp Fiction.
Winner: Lee Meredith