The Heartbreak Kid: Jeannie Berlin (1972) vs. Malin Akerman (2007)
Character: Lila Kolodny
In The Heartbreak Kid, both actresses play Lila, a newlywed whose husband (Charles Grodin the original; Ben Stiller in the remake) finds out on their honeymoon that he's no longer in love with her. So, the question becomes, which actress would a guy be crazier to dump? The above image answers that inquiry quite succinctly.
Winner: Malin Akerman