The Getaway: Ali MacGraw (1972) vs. Kim Basinger (1994)
Character: Carol McCoy
Both Ali MacGraw and Kim Basinger play Carol McCoy, a woman forced to sleep with a mobster in order for her bank robber husband to be released from prison. MacGraw is a great looking woman—there's no doubt about it. Basinger, however, is timeless. She somehow managed to look just as hot in the 2012 film Charlie St. Cloud as she did in 1994's The Getaway.
Winner: Kim Basinger