Character: Kathy Lutz

In both Amityville Horror films, Kathy Lutz isthe matriarch of a family terrorized by demonic forces after moving into a Long Island home that was previously the site of a grisly mass-murder.

Although both are stunning actresses, only one of these ladies has played Lois Lane, and that's Miss Kidder. And if she's good enough for Superman, than she's damn sure good enough for us. Sorry, Melissa. Hope we can still be friends.

Winner: Margot Kidder