Sweet November: Sandy Dennis (1968) vs. Charlize Theron (2001)
Character: Sara Deever
Sandy Dennis is quite attractive, and she gives a fine performance in director Robert Ellis Miller's original version of Sweet November. In fact, Miller's film is ten times better than director Pat O'Connor's Keanu Reeves-led remake of the romantic drama.
But, having said that, Charlize Theron is, and always will be, Charlize Theron. If any sane, straight man's mind was a club, Charlize would have a permanent reservation, complete with free bottle service in its VIP area.
Winner: Charlize Theron