[REC]/Quarantine: Manuela Velasco (2007) vs Jennifer Carpenter (2008)
Character: Angela Vidal
Unless you're a big-time horror buff, you might not realize that 2008's Quarantine was actually a remake of [REC], a brilliant, absolutely chilling Spanish-language pic released just one year prior. Playing the exact same role, Manuela Velasco and Jennifer Carpenter convincingly freak out as Angela, a television reporter who's trapped inside of a building where a mysterious virus has turned the residents into bloodthirsty killers.
Although we've seen how hot Carpenter can be thanks to Dexter, Velasco looks like she could pass for Shakira's equally hot younger sister.
Winner: Manuela Velasco