Psycho: Vera Miles (1960) vs. Julianne Moore (1998)
Character: Lila Crane
As Lila Crane, both Vera Miles and Julianne Moore were attacked by a knife-wielding Norman Bates as he's dressed in his dead mother's clothes. As preposterously creepy as that is, Miles and Moore somehow managed to lighten the mood with their inherent sex appeal. At the end of the day, however, we're simply suckers for redheads.
Winner: Julianne Moore