Psycho: Janet Leigh (1960) vs. Anne Heche (1998)
Character: Marion Crane
In their respective versions of Psycho, Janet Leigh and Anne Heche play Marion Crane, the Bates Motel patron who becomes the center of the infamous shower scene that's been spoofed and reenacted many times over. But despite their similar character, determining the choice between them is as easy as answering the question of whether Alfred Hitchcock or Gus Van Sant is the better director.
Winner: Janet Leigh