My Bloody Valentine: Lori Hallier (1981) vs. Jaime King (2009)

Character: Sarah Palmer

Both Lori Hallier and Jamie King played Sarah Palmer, a small-town cutie who's forced to relive the tragic events of a Valentine's Day massacre carried out by a homicidal maniac wearing a miner's suit.

In the 1981 original, Hallier isn't even the sexiest lady on screen; that honor goes to Cynthia Dale, who plays her best friend, Patty. Even though the remake's naked co-star Betsy Rue provides the film's most provocative sequence, King, the 2009 version's top-billed actress, slightly edges her out.

Winner: Jaime King