Mighty Joe Young: Terry Moore (1949) vs. Charlize Theron (1998)
Character: Jill Young
As Jill Young, both Terry Moore and Charlize Theron had to fend off evil poachers and protect a 16-foot-tall gorilla. While both ladies looked wildly attractive while defending the lovable primate, only one of them is Charlize Theron. Sorry, Terry.
Winner: Charlize Theron