Halloween: Jamie Lee Curtis (1978) vs. Scout Taylor-Compton (2007)
Character: Laurie Strode
While playing Laurie Strode, the perpetually shrieking babysitter terrorized by escaped mental patient Michael Myers, Jamie Lee Curtis and Scout Taylor-Compton each aptly screamed with the petrified energy of near-death victims. However, it would be blasphemy to say that anything director Rob Zombie did with his remake was better than what was done in John Carpenter's original film.
Winner: Jamie Lee Curtis