Day of the Dead: Lori Cardille (1985) vs. Mena Suvari (2008)
Character: Sarah Bowman
In Hollywood, horror movie remakes are like sandwiches: Everybody wants to make one. So it should come as no surprise that, in 2008, there was a remake of George Romero's 1985 zombie gem Day of the Dead, this time directed by Steve Miner. The original film was vastly better than the remake; however, in our eyes, the 2008 version did have the hotter woman-with-a-gun.
Winner: Mena Suvari