Neighborhood: Park Slope, Brooklyn
Address: 85 5th Ave.
Website: n/a

This Park Slope moneymaker gets an A+ rating. The Margarita slice is just the beginning of what's served daily. We love its soft, thick, crust that folds easily, just like a well-worn baseball glove. The sauce, cheese, and crust define the overall taste in every single bite. But don't eat with your eyes. These stacked pies are hella filling.