Neighborhood: Belmont, Bronx
Address: 2342 Arthur Ave.

Family-owned for five generations, this old-fashioned, charming restaurant has attracted people to Arthur Avenue for decades. The pie is light and crisp, always covered with a fresh, delicious sauce. But don't take our word for it—The Sopranos filmed here, which is a truly remarkable compliment to pay to a classic pizzeria. Can't stop, won't stop.