Neighborhood: Gravesend, Brooklyn
Address: 2725 86th St.
Website: spumonigardens.com

The square pie drives Brooklynites bananas. Thick dough, melted oozing cheese, everything topped off with lots of sauce. Not your traditional-style Sicilian, but you'll still need the extra napkins. In summertime, this place truly comes alive. The front yard is always packed with people hanging out. Don't be surprised if you see cars tripled parked. Enjoying pizza with friends and family in this atmosphere is second to none!