Neighborhood: DUMBO, Brooklyn
Address: 19 Old Fulton St.
Website: grimaldisnyc.com

Any pizza lover will always have Grimaldi's in their top five. This OG spot under the Brooklyn Bridge is never at a standstill—ever. Hundreds of people waiting in line from opening to closing. Tour buses roll up all day, every day. How could you not love a pizzeria, where the nostalgia to get in is almost as impactful as the savory taste of each slice? This is that one spot where people make excuses to return if they find out their friends and family have never heard of their greatness. Order a pie. Get creative and add some toppings. Trust us, you'll be back for more! FYI: Don't get caught out there; it's cash only.