Most Dominant Year: 2011

We know what you're thinking. This should be Ray Lewis, right? Wrong, because at least in Madden, 49ers linebacker Willis is a far superior player. A year ago, he was a middle linebacker with a 90 Speed rating, 96 Acceleration, 99 Stamina and 99 Tackle. That made him fast enough to stay with some receivers and corners, good enough to tackle the biggest, baddest tailbacks. Oh, and he had enough endurance to contend in the Boston Marathon. Willis is the kind of player you think about creating. But you never create him, because he provides an unfair advantage for seasoned gamers.