Most Dominant Year: 2010

Even if MJD wasn't a Pro Bowl-caliber tailback, the Jacksonville Jaguars runner would make this list for one reason: He actually PLAYS the video game when he has time. Yes, Jones-Drew is a hardcore Madden gamer, folks. But he's also a deathly effective tailback, too, regularly ranking among the fastest runners in the game and featuring surprising strength for a 5-7 running back. Oh, and did we mention that he can catch the ball?