Most Dominant Year: 2006

These days, the 34-year-old quarterback is rapidly sliding into journeyman status, getting ready to play for his third team in three years. But back in 2005, he was a certifiable star for the Philadelphia Eagles, having teamed with a certain Terrell Owens to catapult Philly to the Super Bowl and landed on the Madden 06 cover. McNabb didn't quite have the wheels of some quarterbacks, but he did boast a dangerous enough Speed rating, which, combined with his strength, allowed him to shake off would-be tacklers.