Most Dominant Year: 2008

In real life, Antonio Cromartie is Darrelle Revis' understudy, but in Madden, he's the class of the corners. The Jets cover man stands a rangy 6-3, which leads to a lot of pass interference calls in reality. In Madden, though, he's the perfect height to stay with big wideouts like Terrell Owens. In 2008, EA gave Cromartie a 97 Speed rating and, realizing his penchant for flashy interceptions, they gave him a high Spectacular Catch rating. The result was the finest ball-hawking CB in the history of the game. He's not rated quite that high these days, but he's still among the game's best defenders.