When: 2002 to 2003
Jeter's relationship with the Yale graduate and Fast and Furious actress became official in the summer of 2002, when The Daily News printed a cover of the two kissing and holding hands at his 28th birthday party. The relationship continued for months with the couple being seen holiday shopping later that year, and reports of Brewster telling friends it's serious and "I just don't want to jinx it." However, when Jeter was a no-show at her birthday party the following April, it was obvious he was on to the next one.
Smash Probability: