When: 2006 to 2007
Though Jeter and the actress had been seen at Hollywood Social in mid-November, they didn't go public until a few weeks later when they were seen on vacation together in Las Vegas. Throughout their relationship, the couple could be seen on public outings such as their vacation in Puerto Rico. Reports of the couple's split began to surface after she was seen flirting with Justin Timberlake that January while Jeter was in the Bahamas for the Michael Jordan golf tournament. Cry us a river.
Smash Probability: