2. Old Town Bar
Address: 45 East 18th St.
Price: $9.50 (small); $13.25 (large)
Manhattan's Old Town Bar has been pouring pints since 1892, making it one of New York's oldest neighborhood bars. Old Town serves a single type of Buffalo wing—they're craftsmen over there—and while petite, the wings are consistent in quality. In fact, these are textbook Buffalo wings, dripping in that butter-and-Frank's combo.