Roger Says: Connolly’s is only open in the summer and on St. Patrick’s Day. It’s a surfer bar where tons of firemen and police officers drink. There are pictures on the walls of the lifeguards of Rockaway Beach, and they must have some kind of Best Body Contest because they have pictures of all of the winners inside. And the piña coladas, they’re ridiculous. I don’t drink too many piña coladas, but these are the real deal. They're strong. You can taste the rum.